Plots/Graphics: As mentioned above in the ozone operational evaluation, graphics are a

useful means for understanding how predictions and observations differ. For PM evaluations we

recommend creating time series plots, tile plots, and scatter plots. Time series plots tell whether

there is any particular time of day, day(s) of the week, or months (seasons) of the year when the

model performs poorly. Tile plots reveal geographic locations where the model performs poorly.

Information from tile plots and time series may provide clues about where to focus quality

assurance efforts for model inputs. Scatter plots show whether there is any part of the distribution

of observations for which the model performs poorly. These plots are also useful for helping to

interpret calculations of bias between observations and predictions. For example, they could

show large differences between component PM2.5 observations and predictions which just happen

to balance, producing low estimated aggregated bias. As mentioned above, since the NAAQS for

PM2.5 and the regional haze goals will likely require modeling different times of year, seasonspecific

graphic displays are helpful for evaluating and diagnosing model performance.

These above mentioned graphical plots have been provided as examples in the ozone

operational evaluation section. Other graphical analysis displays can also be developed to better

inform a model performance evaluation. Additional types of graphical plots are shown below.

These plots were generated using the AMET tool.

Figure 18.4 shows an example of a “soccer plot” and “bugle plots” (Boylan, 2006)

(Tesche, 2006). The soccer plot is so named because the dotted lines resemble a soccer goal. The

plot is a convenient way to visualize model performance, as measures of both bias and error are

shown on a single plot. As bias and error approach zero, the points are plotted closer to or within

the “goal”, represented here by the dashed boxes. The “bugle plot”, named for the shape formed

by the criteria and goal lines, is another plot available for model performance evaluation. The

bugle plots are shaped as such because the goal and criteria lines are adjusted based on the

average concentration of the observed species. As the average concentration becomes smaller,

the criteria and goal lines become larger to adjust for the model’s ability to predict at low

concentrations. We recommend allowing for larger bias and error when the ambient

concentration falls below 2 ug/m3.


n851 - n852 - n853 - n854 - n855 - n856 - n857 - n858 - n859 - n860 - n861 - n862 - n863 - n864 - n865 - n866 - n867 - n868 - n869 - n870 - n871 - n872 - n873 - n874 - n875 - n876 - n877 - n878 - n879 - n880 - n881 - n882 - n883 - n884 - n885 - n886 - n887 - n888 - n889 - n890 - n891 - n892 - n893 - n894 - n895 - n896 - n897 - n898 - n899 - n900


   Flag of Portugal 



 castellano: DISPER CUSTIC DESCAR RADIA    italiano:     


 français:    português:  






deutsch: DIS CUS  DES  RAD

castellano: DIS CUS DES  RAD   english: DIS CUS DES RAD  


 português: DIS CUS DES RAD   italiano:   DIS CUS  DES RAD


français:  DIS CUS DES RAD